Interviewes with victims, witnesses and accused outside the courts | ||||||||||||||||
Interview Date | 10.12.2013 | 10.12.2013 | 10.12.2013 | 01.12.2013 | 27.11.2013 | 27.11.2013 | 27.11.2013 | 27.11.2013 | 26.11.2013 | 26.11.2013 | 27.11.13 | 27.11.13 | ||||
Q. No. | Questions | Comilla | Gopalgonj | Madaripur | Mymensingh | Rangpur | ||||||||||
Check number | 1 person | 8 persons | 13 persons | 4 persons, 3 male and 1 female | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 women and 7 men interviewed | 1 man | 1 woman | 1 | 1 | 1 woman | ||
1 | Why are you here? | I have come with the criminal. | I am the criminal of 29/30 | I am the criminal | Victim | Witness | Witness | Witness | Witness | 1.
Came as a witness 2. I support a party 3. I am a victim of crime |
Case [unable to translate] | Witness
(defence) |
someone else has occupied our land | Victim | My husband is in prison as a victim of conspiracy of murder | |
2 | Is this the first time you have come to court for this case? | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No > Some of them come here multiple times before |
No | No | No | No | No | |
2a | If NO: How many times have you attended before | 3 times. | 50
times (3 to 4 yrs) |
I have been coming for 16 years. | No, 5 times. | 2 times | 24 or 25 times | 3 times | 30-35 times | 1.
2 people: 4 times 2. 3 people: 6 times 3. 5 people: 3 times; |
4 times | 5 times | 2 | 4 | 35 | |
2b | How many times have you given evidence? | Never | N/A | Never | Never | I didn't | 1 time | 2 times | 4 times | |||||||
2c | How many of you will come next time? | All | 2 persons | 4 persons | All people asked will come again, | Yes | Yes > Out of 19, 15 male and 4 female told that All of us will come |
No > The case was settled outside of the court. |
Yes | When lawyers call me | ||||||
2d | If YES have you completed your evidence | No. | No. | No | Not applicable | No > It is not finished yet. |
No | No | ||||||||
3 | How much does it cost you to come here each time in total? | Minimum 40, maximum 100. | Minimum 1200, maximum 3000. | Min: 250 taka; Max: 350 | Minimum 1000, maximum 2000. | Minimum 300 taka, maximum 400 | Minimum: 2,500; Maximum: 3,000 | Min: 250 taka; Max: 350 | Min: 1,000; Max: 2,500 | Some 200 taka, some 275 taka, some 300 taka | 300 taka | From minimum- 100,000 | From minimum- 40000 | From minimum- 35000 | ||
4 | How far have you travelled to get here today? | Minimum 35, maximum 40 | Minimum 30, maximum 40 | Minimum 5 miles, maximum 10 miles. | Minimum 19 miles, maximum no answer. | 35 kilometers | Maximum: 70 kilometers | Max: 29 kilometer | Min: 50 kilometers | Some of them 10 miles, 15 miles, 18 miles, and 28 miles | 25 kilometers | From minimum- 40 to 50 Km | From minimum- 30 Km | From minimum- 50 Km | ||
5 | Can you afford these costs? | Yes | No | No | No | No | No | No | Yes | Some of them by himself, some by relatives, some by NGO | No > Girls provide this expense |
No | Yes | No > I had to sell mor 30-40 bigha land. Don't know what will happen |
It is suffering me severly. I had to sell my land | No > I am suffering. I have to work in house and had to sell a cow |
6 | Are you satisfied with your experience at court today? | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | 6 are satisfied, 4 are not satisfied | No | Yes | Yes | Not at all | No | No | |
7 | If no, why not? Record answer | How can I be satisfied! I and my boy have served sentence for a false case. | 1.
I suffer for coming and going 2. Case is running for a long time 3. We have to come even if the plaintiff does not come |
1.
We general people stand there, no place to sit, 2. The date of hearing is changing for 5 years, how can I be satisfied 3. We have to come even if the plaintiff does not come. |
How can I be satisifed because I have already served sentence for a false case? The advocate does not appear if I can give him adequate money. | I have not given witness yet. | Did not take witness yet. | If my testimony was taken today, then my money, time, and job would not be harmed. | The court system cannot finish the full hearing; my client didn't get the bail | The police could not arrest all my opponent person | The case is running for a long time. I can not take it any more. | I don't understand what does the lawyer do | He was supposed to get bail, but he has not got it yet | |||
[1] | ||||||||||||||||